Expert Of My Own Experience

I was reading this article in the Huffington Post about Breastfeeding and thinking, again, about the so called Mummy Wars I’ve been hearing a lot about recently. Arguments between people, often Mothers (sometimes Fathers) about how they raise their children.

I’ve watched some discussions take place on Twitter about how people have handled feeding, weaning, sleeping, tantrums, education etc with their own children. I spend a lot of time questioning whether I’m doing the right thing with Joni, because – let’s face it – this is the steepest learning curve of my life so far. I’ve already done a whole host of things that I’ll do differently next time, why? Because I’ve become an Expert Of My Own Experience. And, I am the expert on Joni. I know more about her than anyone ever will. I can decipher her talking – we have whole conversations that only me, her and her Dad understand. No one knows her like we do. So, whilst controlled crying – as an example – might have worked a treat for your child, it hasn’t worked for us and we won’t be trying it again. Why? Because my expert knowledge tells me not to.

I do read books about parenting. I’ve tried to steer clear of How To guides as such, opting for slightly more academic books with lots of research. But that is because that’s my background. In a past life I was all about Evidence Based Practice and improving quality through research. So, naturally, that’s how I approach my research into how to raise my child. I also consult experts in my own life: my Mum, her Mum, aunties and friends. Often, because they are experts on me, and are close to Joni, they can help us along the way.

I was recently inspired and encouraged by this blog post from Ministry of Mum – I couldn’t agree more with the sentiment. Whatever Works. And, as my own Mum pointed out, the emphasis she puts of the parents sleep being really important is a serious point for me. I can’t really function as a rational or normal human being without enough sleep. So I get it whenever and however I can (and wherever for that matter). Because my expert knowledge tells me that me getting enough sleep is better for my life and the lives of those close to me. As an Expert, I choose Whatever Works.

I spent some time in my early twenties trying to understand how my parents raised me and why they did the things they did. My Dad once said this ‘your mother and I did what we felt was best at the time with the resources we had’. After some pondering I realised: of course. Because they loved me. Because they wanted the best for me. Because they chose to have me. Looking back, not everything they did was perfect. Of course. Who could do a job for 18 years and not make a mistake?

These so called Mummy Wars (you know: breastfeeding vs formula, cloth vs disposable nappies, Gina Ford vs Attachment Parenting, staying at home vs going to work, BLW vs Purée, I could go on and and on and on.) are more worrying for a more serious reason though. In fact I’d go as far as to say they scare me. Why the division? Why be so evangelical? One thing worked for you and your family. It solved your sleeping/weaning/feeding issue: GREAT. I want to hear about it and understand it, but as an Expert Of My Own Experience I want to be allowed to, respectfully, not apply your idea to my own family. Or, to take from it what I can and expertly apply it to my family. I want to be able to admit that I was wrong and I changed what I did because of something you said or did without feeling like a failure.

So, who is creating these Mummy Wars? We all decided to have children for roughly the same reason and everyone wants what is best for theirs. There are really very few people out there who don’t. We are the majority – we want the very best and to do the very best and a lot of the time we agonise over what the best is for our children. This is what should unite us all as parents. A mutual understand that as Experts we will do Whatever Works to raise our children and we will share these experiences in a way that helps each other – not starts wars or factions or labels people as ‘brigades’. So, I’d like to advocate Supportive Parenting.

Where we aren’t in a war about what is ‘best’ but – as a group of Experts – we can share our own experiences, take advice, but most of all be confident that we are ‘doing the right thing’, or attempting to, and are supported by other parents as we do it.

And, for your viewing pleasure, here’s Joni in a moment of despair (and flag waving)

20120804-063234.jpg

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Parenting and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Expert Of My Own Experience

  1. Joanna says:

    I feel exactly the same way and I think it’s a positive thing that according to Oliver James (http://www.amazon.co.uk/How-Not-F-Them-Up/dp/0091923913) says pretty much the same thing. About 50% of parents / mothers go between being controlling and letting the baby lead the way. They adjust and that’s the best thing.

    I’ve kind of noticed the debates but more often I’ve taken advice where it suits me and ignored what doesn’t. A huge thing is me getting enough sleep and M feeling supported and loved. Sometimes boundaries do that but not when they are just there for my convenience.

    I think the people who are always supportive are the same when it comes to these things and the others just play out the roles they always have. Argumentative and controlling people employ the same techniques when it comes to children and other parents. The only thing that really annoys me is the media playing the sides against each other. Even the Guardian acts like the Daily Mail just to get a rise out of mothers. We are the targetted demographic in so many things. It’s appalling and tedious.

    Lovely post and beautiful Joni! xxx

  2. Lydia says:

    This is one of the many things I love about Twitter. The parents I interact with (including you!) are all of this opinion. It’s a great way to vent, ask advice or get much-needed support without fear of being judged. And as Jo says, if any advice doesn’t suit we can choose to ignore it.

    It’s unfortunate that not all parents feel the same way and not everyone has this level of support. Confidence plays a big part and as you say, knowing that we are the only ones who can say for sure what’s right for our child(ren).

    I began parenting Max & Finn the the same but as they grow, I’m learning that each requires a different approach to parenting and what works for one doesn’t necessarily for the other. Proof indeed that a one-size-fits-all approach isn’t for us!

    A great post, thanks Emma x

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s